Most agencies aren't like that. But you can't tell from the pitch, and the pitch is usually all you get before you sign.

The quick answer: decide what job you're hiring an agency for before you talk to one, then judge them on evidence rather than presentation. Speak to two past clients without the agency on the call. Ask to see live numbers on a screen-share, not screenshots. Meet the people who'll do your work. Start with the shortest paid pilot that can show a real signal for that channel, judged on one number you agreed in advance. And walk away from guaranteed outcomes, big upfront fees with vague scope, and anyone who won't give you admin on your own accounts.

Why is choosing an agency harder in 2026?

Choosing an agency is harder in 2026 for two reasons: how agencies now get paid, and how easily reach can be faked. First, more of what agencies earn comes from the media they buy for you, not the hours they bill. Forrester expects close to a third of agency billings in 2026 to come from principal media, where the agency buys inventory and resells it to you at a margin (Decision Marketing). That's legitimate, but it means an agency can earn more by recommending more spend. So before you ask what they'd do, ask how they get paid on every line.

Second, in crypto, reach claims are easy to fake and hard to trust. In September 2025, investigator ZachXBT published a spreadsheet he said showed the influencers approached for a paid token campaign: around 160 had accepted and fewer than five labelled their posts as ads (The Block). If an agency's plan leans on a KOL network, you're inheriting that risk.

And for anyone marketing crypto to UK consumers, the stakes are rising. The FCA has published final rules for the new UK cryptoasset regime, its authorisation gateway opened on 30 September 2026, and the regime is expected to apply from 25 October 2027 (Lewis Silkin). In the meantime, the financial promotion rules already apply. Since 8 October 2023, anyone promoting qualifying cryptoassets to UK consumers has had to use one of four lawful routes: the promotion is communicated by an FCA-authorised person; approved by an FCA-authorised person with the appropriate permissions; communicated by or on behalf of an FCA-registered cryptoasset business under the Article 73ZA exemption; or otherwise communicated in accordance with an exemption in the Financial Promotion Order. Every promotion still has to be fair, clear and not misleading, carry the required risk warnings and follow the limits on incentives. Don't outsource that decision to the agency. Agree who approves each promotion before anything goes live.

What should you decide before you talk to any agency?

Decide what job the agency is for before you speak to any of them. Agencies are good at execution: paid media, PR, content, SEO, community. They're rarely set up to decide your positioning or which channel to bet on, and the ones who say they will are usually selling you the channel they're best at.

If you don't know yet what you need doing, you probably need a strategy decision first, not an agency. That's the difference between the two we cover in fractional CMO vs agency vs full-time hire.

How do you check an agency is what it says it is?

You can check an agency with five quick tests: speak to past clients alone, see real data, meet the people doing the work, verify the team size, and read the contract for exits.

  1. Speak to past clients, alone. Ask for two, and call them without the agency on the line. Ask what went wrong, not what went right.
  2. See real data. Ask them to screen-share a live ad account or dashboard for fifteen minutes, with the client's agreement, or have the reference client show you the numbers on your call. A slide of results proves nothing.
  3. Meet the doers. Find out who will actually work on your account, and meet them before you sign. The senior people in the pitch often aren't.
  4. Check the size claim. LinkedIn takes ten minutes. If the team page says thirty and you can find four, ask why.
  5. Read the contract for exits. Notice period, who owns the ad accounts and the content, and what happens to your data if you leave.

One more check worth adding in 2026: ask how the agency's headcount has changed over the last year, and who on your account would be affected by further cuts. With Forrester forecasting a 15% cut in agency headcount this year (Decision Marketing), it's a fair question and a good agency will answer it straight.

What are the red flags?

The biggest red flags are guaranteed outcomes, a large upfront fee with vague scope, costs that only go up, reports on activity instead of customers, and no admin access to your own accounts.

Red flag What it usually looks like What to ask
Guaranteed outcomes We'll sell out your launch, or 10x your followers What happened on the last project where it didn't work?
Big upfront fee, vague scope A large first invoice before any work is defined What exactly is delivered in month one, and how will we judge it?
Costs that only go up Each month needs one more line item to ensure success What was the original budget meant to achieve, and did it?
Activity reports, not outcomes Impressions, reach and likes, nothing on customers How many of these people became customers, and stayed?
No access to your own accounts They run the ads, you see screenshots Can I have admin on every account you run for us?
Follower and engagement spikes Overnight jumps with no sales behind them Where did these followers come from?

How do you know if an agency isn't working?

An agency isn't working if, after three months, it can't show movement in the one number you agreed at the start, or keeps changing which number matters. To find out early, run a paid pilot with a go or no-go on that number, and if you extend, review again at ninety days. Eight weeks works for most paid, creative and campaign work. SEO, PR and brand need a longer window, so agree the leading indicators before you sign. Good agencies bring you bad news early. Weak ones bring you more reports.

What should you ask an agency's past clients?

  1. What were you promised at the start, and what did you actually get?
  2. What went wrong, and how did they handle it?
  3. Who did the day-to-day work, and was it the people from the pitch?
  4. What did it cost per customer, not per click?
  5. Would you hire them again for the same job?
  6. What would you change in the contract if you signed again?

What should the pilot scorecard look like?

Write it down before the pilot starts and get the agency to agree it. An example for a paid acquisition pilot:

Measure Baseline Target at week 8 Kill threshold Review
Cost per activated customer £85 £60 Above £95 at week 6 Fortnightly
Customers still active at day 30 35% 40% Below 30% Week 8
Share of sign-ups traceable to a channel 50% 90% Below 80% Week 2

Which contract terms should you insist on?

Insist on five terms: short notice with no auto-renewal, ownership of every account and asset, itemised fees, disclosed media margins, and named people on your account.

  • Thirty days' notice once the pilot ends, with no auto-renewal
  • You own everything: the ad accounts, the data, the creative and the content, with admin access from day one
  • Fees and media spend itemised separately on every invoice
  • Any media margin disclosed. If they buy media and resell it to you, you should know the margin on every line
  • Named people on your account, with notice if they change

Does this change for crypto and Web3?

For crypto and Web3 the checks are the same, but the stakes are higher, because launch dates are fixed, communities judge you in public, and fake engagement is cheap to buy. Ask any crypto agency or KOL network to show you wallet or conversion data behind their reach, not just follower counts.

So what should you do before you sign?

Before you sign any agency, ask yourself one question. If this agency disappeared in three months, would you know exactly what they'd done and whether it worked? If the honest answer is no, don't sign until it's yes.